kb-criminal-procedure-lb
Rating is derived from the repo's GitHub stars and shown for reference.
name: kb-criminal-procedure-lb
description: Use when advising on Lebanese criminal procedure, including the role of the Investigating Judge (juge d'instruction), the Public Prosecutor (Niyaba 'Amma), detention and pretrial rights, the court structure (Judicial Court of First Instance, Court of Appeal, Court of Cassation), the distinct criminal jurisdictions (military court, Judicial Council, personal status courts), white-collar crime, and the practical challenges of the Lebanese judicial system under the ongoing crisis. French-derived system with Lebanese adaptations.
license: MIT
metadata:
id: kb.criminal-procedure-LB
category: kb
practice_area: Criminal Law & Procedure
jurisdictions: [LB]
priority: P2
intent: [Lebanese criminal procedure, criminal law Lebanon, juge d'instruction, detention, Lebanese courts, white-collar crime]
related: [kb-aml-fatf-mena, kb-banking-regulation-bdl, kb-criminal-procedure-uae, kb-corporate-law-lb]
source: Louis — HAQQ Legal AI (github.com/sboghossian/mini-claude-for-legal)
version: "1.0"
Knowledge Pack — Criminal Procedure in Lebanon
Scope
This pack covers Lebanese criminal procedure, its French-derived inquisitorial structure, and the practical realities of the Lebanese judicial system particularly under the post-2019 financial and political crisis. It covers:
- Legal sources and structure
- Court hierarchy
- Investigation: role of the Investigating Judge (juge d'instruction)
- Arrest, detention, and rights
- Right to counsel
- Trial procedure
- Key substantive criminal law relevant to business
- White-collar and financial crime
- Practical concerns and crisis impact
Primary legal sources
| Statute | Scope |
|---|---|
| Code of Criminal Procedure (CPC) (Decree-Law 328/1994 as amended) | Procedural rules; inquisitorial model |
| Penal Code (Decree-Law 340/1943 as amended) | General criminal offences; largely unchanged from French-influenced 1943 code |
| Special laws | AML (Law 44/2015), cybercrime (Law 81/2018 e-signature touches digital evidence), drugs, financial crimes |
Court structure
| Court | Jurisdiction |
|---|---|
| Juge d'Instruction (Investigating Judge) | Investigates serious crimes; issues warrants; decides on detention |
| Juge Unique (Single Judge) | Minor offences (contraventions, misdemeanors) |
| Chambre Correctionnelle | Tribunal of first instance for misdemeanors and moderate felonies |
| Cour d'Assises (Court of Assizes) | Serious felonies (crimes); three-judge panel + no jury system |
| Court of Appeal (Cour d'Appel) | Appellate review of criminal matters; Beirut CA is primary |
| Court of Cassation (Cour de Cassation) | Final appeal on legal questions only |
| Military Court | Military personnel; also has jurisdiction over some civilian cases involving weapons or military offences |
| Judicial Council (Majlis al-Qada' al-A'la) | Exceptional tribunal for cases affecting state security |
The investigating judge (juge d'instruction)
Lebanon uses the inquisitorial model inherited from French law. The juge d'instruction (investigating judge) is the central figure in serious criminal matters:
- Appointed to investigate specific files (dossiers)
- Conducts investigation: interviews witnesses and suspects, orders searches, examines documents, appoints experts
- Independent of the prosecution — investigates both incriminating and exculpatory evidence
- Decides on detention orders (mandat de dépôt)
- Issues referral (renvoi) to trial court, or dismissal (non-lieu)
Key difference from common-law systems: The investigating judge's file (dossier d'instruction) is the basis of the trial; the trial court judges the case partly on the basis of the investigation file, not just what is presented at hearing.
Investigation, arrest, and detention
Arrest
- Arrest can be made:
- On order of the Public Prosecutor (Niyaba 'Amma) — for initial investigation
- On order of the Investigating Judge (juge d'instruction) — once investigation opened
- In flagrante delicto by police/gendarmerie
Pre-trial detention
- Administrative detention (garde à vue): up to 48 hours by police; extendable by Public Prosecutor to maximum 4 days total before referral to investigating judge
- Judicial detention (mandat de dépôt): ordered by investigating judge; renewable; can extend for months or years in complex cases (notorious for length in white-collar matters)
- Conditions: detained persons must be informed of reasons; right to family notification
Pre-trial release
- Investigating judge may release on bail (liberté provisoire)
- Release on personal pledge, surety, or cash bail
- Travel ban (mandat d'interdiction de سفر) frequently imposed in financial crime cases
Right to counsel
- Right to a lawyer from the time of arrest (CPC reforms)
- Lawyer must be a member of the Lebanese Bar Association
- Access during garde à vue: practically, access to counsel during initial police custody is not always immediate
- Access during juge d'instruction phase: lawyer has full access to the investigation file (dossier)
- Lebanese Bar has a duty lawyer scheme for those who cannot afford counsel
Substantive criminal law — key categories
General offences (Penal Code 1943)
- Homicide, assault, theft, fraud (escroquerie), breach of trust (détournement), forgery (faux en écriture)
- The 1943 Penal Code provisions remain largely in force but have been supplemented by special laws
Financial and white-collar crime
- Fraud (escroquerie): using fraudulent means to obtain property — Penal Code
- Breach of trust (abus de confiance): misappropriation of entrusted property
- Embezzlement: specific provisions for public officials
- Money laundering: Law 44/2015 — up to 7 years imprisonment + fines + asset confiscation
- Tax evasion: tax code provisions
Banking crisis-related offences
The financial crisis has generated significant criminal litigation:
- Capital flight: accusations of wrongful transfer of funds abroad — politically charged; judicial investigations ongoing
- Market manipulation: investigations related to pre-crisis financial engineering
- Bank officials: prosecutions of bank officers for specific acts remain politically sensitive but have been pursued in some cases
Cybercrime
Limited cybercrime-specific law; Law 81/2018 on e-signature provides some digital evidence rules. General fraud and forgery provisions apply to computer-based crimes. Lebanon is a party to the Budapest Convention on Cybercrime.
Trial procedure
Preparation
The trial court receives the investigation dossier. Parties submit pre-trial briefs.
Hearing
- Public hearing in principle (exceptions for security or personal reasons)
- Presiding judge reads charges
- Examination of witnesses and experts
- Defendant questioned
- Prosecution and defence closing arguments
- Deliberation and judgment (can be reserved)
Standard of proof
The court must be intimement convaincu (intimately convinced) of guilt — equivalent to the civil-law version of beyond reasonable doubt.
Appeals
- Full appeal on facts and law to the Court of Appeal (Cour d'Appel)
- Cassation appeal on legal grounds only (Court of Cassation)
Practical challenges — crisis context (2019+)
Judicial capacity
Lebanon's judiciary has been severely impacted by the financial and political crisis:
- Judicial salaries collapsed in LBP terms; brain drain of judges
- Court operations disrupted by rolling strikes by judicial staff
- Case backlogs extend to years
- Electronic filing systems have been introduced but inconsistently implemented
International dimensions
- Interpol notices (Red Notices) have been issued against some individuals in connection with financial crisis-related allegations
- Swiss and French courts have opened investigations into Lebanese bank accounts and capital flight
- Mutual legal assistance requests to Lebanon have variable response times
Asset recovery
Lebanese prosecutors and investigating judges have sought to freeze and recover assets related to the financial crisis. These efforts face:
- Bank secrecy constraints (being progressively removed)
- Political complexity around accountability
- Coordination challenges with foreign jurisdictions where assets may have moved
How to use this pack
Load this pack when:
- A client or their executives face criminal investigation or charges in Lebanon
- Advising on AML exposure, financial crime, or crisis-related criminal liability in Lebanon
- Conducting due diligence requiring understanding of Lebanese criminal exposure
- Advising on cooperation with foreign authorities regarding Lebanon-linked criminal matters
Caveats & currency
Lebanese criminal procedure is formally governed by the 1994 CPC but practical realities of the crisis significantly affect the functioning of the system. Political considerations affect certain prosecutions. Verify the status of any specific case or investigation with Lebanese-licensed criminal counsel. The situation is highly dynamic.
Related skills
- [[kb-aml-fatf-mena]] — AML/CFT and SIC framework for Lebanon
- [[kb-banking-regulation-bdl]] — crisis context for financial crime
- [[kb-criminal-procedure-uae]] — UAE criminal procedure for comparison
- [[kb-corporate-law-lb]] — Lebanese corporate law context